Rare and controversial early Monopoly acquired by Strong Museum of Play


featuredImage
This circa 1910-1917 folk art Monopoly game hand drawn and colored by John O. Heap, used in a trademark infringement case, was purchased for $10,350 at Noel Barrett's Spring Auction held May 1-2 in New Hope, Pa., by the Strong Museum of Play. Photos courtesy Strong Museum of Play

ROCHESTER, N.Y. – Who really invented Monopoly?

A rare and unique early version of Monopoly, used as evidence in a controversial, 10-year legal copyright battle over the iconic American game’s true inventor, has been acquired by Strong National Museum of Play in Rochester, N.Y.—home of the National Toy Hall of Fame.

The museum is pleased to announce that the second oldest known version of the world’s most popular board game ever has been added to its world-renowned collections of play-related objects: a folk-art Monopoly game created by a member of the Heap family between 1910 and 1917 when the family lived in Altoona, Pa. The Heap board game also has the distinction of being the oldest Monopoly game with all its playing pieces intact, including hand-made money, property cards in color groupings, and houses and other “improvement” buildings. The Heap game was an important piece of evidence in a Monopoly copyright dispute that began in 1974 and spanned a decade.

To briefly summarize the copyright disagreement: Pennsylvanian Charles Darrow claimed to have invented the game of Monopoly and sold the rights to Parker Brothers in 1935. In 1973, Ralph Anspach, a professor of economics, invented a game called Anti-Monopoly™; and, in 1974, became embroiled in a lawsuit for trademark infringement brought against him by the General Mills Fun Group. While Anspach never drew a “Go to Jail!” card in his legal battle over the Monopoly copyright—his case dragged on for 10 years, eventually landing in the Supreme Court.

In his own defense, Anspach uncovered a number of earlier versions of Monopoly—what he referred to as “folk art” games that were introduced long before Charles Darrow’s 1930s “invention”; among them, the Heap version, recently purchased by Strong National Museum of Play. The existence of this hand-drawn and colored pre-Monopoly game provided evidence that Darrow, popularly credited as the inventor of Monopoly, was not the actual inventor after all, and helped lead to Anspach’s ultimate judicial victory.

According to Strong curator Nic Ricketts, “John Heap, grandson of the inventor of the Heap game, also testified at Anspach’s trial and remembered playing this game as a child as early as 1913 and calling it ‘monopoly.’ This important new acquisition helps us to show the history of one of the nation’s most popular games ever, and one of the iconic toys that is honored in our own National Toy Hall of Fame.”

Strong National Museum of Play owns approximately 65 additional Monopoly sets and related games; among them a rare, early version by Charles Darrow, hand-colored on oilcloth rollup board — one of only two such existing versions of the game (and the one in best condition). Strong is contemplating a special display of both the Heap and the early Darrow Monopoly games during the museum’s National Toy Hall of Fame induction on Nov. 4, 2010.

Strong National Museum of Play is the only museum in the world devoted to the study of play and is home to the world’s most comprehensive collection of play-related objects including games, toys, dolls, and electronic games. You can learn more about the museum and visit its online collections at www.museumofplay.org. ?


MORE RESOURCES FOR ANTIQUE COLLECTORS and DEALERS

Great books, CDs, price guides & more

Warman’s Antiques & Collectibles 2011 Price Guide

Interact with other antique collectors in Antique Trader’s online forum

Browse hundreds of FREE online classified ads

Sign up for your FREE AntiqueTrader.com email newsletter

For more columns and features for antique dealers, restorers and collectors, get your own subscription to Antique Trader magazine

More Images:

featuredImage
This circa 1910-1917 folk art Monopoly game hand drawn and colored by John O. Heap, used in a trademark infringement case, was purchased for $10,350 at Noel Barrett's Spring Auction held May 1-2 in New Hope, Pa., by the Strong Museum of Play.

Leave a Reply