Target ball sale shows strong market for ‘glass ephemera’

The auction was conducted online from July 15-22 by American Bottle Auctions of Sacramento.


featuredImage
This target ball made in the 1870s by Agnew & Brown sold for a record price of $29,120. Photos courtesy American Bottle Auctions

SACRAMENTO, Calif. – An Agnew & Brown 3-inch target ball from the 1870s, showing an embossed pigeon on the reverse side and quite possibly the only picture target ball ever made in glass, soared to $29,120 – a new world record for a target ball at auction – in an online auction held July 15-22 by American Bottle Auctions.

The ball was the top lot at Part 2 of the Peter Frobouck collection. Part 1 was held March 29 of this year. Approximately 30 rare, vintage target balls were featured at each auction. Frobouck hails from Pittsburgh, as did Agnew & Brown when the firm was active in the late 19th century. That was when all target balls were made, before giving way to clay pigeons (or skeet).

Not many people are familiar with target balls. They are a small but slowly growing genre of collectible, especially popular today among well-to-do hunters and gun enthusiasts, but a novelty attraction among bottle collectors. Target balls had a brief but colorful life, bursting on the scene around 1876 before fading out altogether by 1895.

During that small window of time glass balls — not all that dissimilar in size and shape to glass Christmas tree ornaments — were stuffed with feathers and sawdust and catapulted from spring-loaded traps to be hit by shooters. They’d explode in the air in a feathery, dusty cloud, as a bird would. In fact, target balls were introduced because the bird population was declining.

During their heyday, target balls were produced by the millions, and not just here in the United States. Manufacturers sprang up in England, France, Germany and Australia, too. These glass orbs sold for a penny apiece back then, but today a rare example like the Agnew & Brown ball can command a hefty price tag. But it’s entirely possible to buy a nice ball for around $200.

“That’s the beauty of target balls,” said Jeff Wichmann of American Bottle Auctions. “It’s a collectible that’s still cozy and small enough that it hasn’t been overrun by big dollar investors looking to drive up prices in the name of a quick profit. Yes, some of the balls cost a lot of money, but that’s because they’re rare and beautiful. But it isn’t that way across the board.”

Factors such as the diversity of patterns, colors and country of origin can all combine to determine a target ball’s worth. Then there’s the cache of a colorful past. Target ball shooting was a sport observed by U.S. presidents, England’s Queen Victoria and the German Kaiser. An early user was Annie Oakley, who blasted target balls at Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Shows.

The Agnew & Brown ball was in near-perfect condition and boasted a nice medium amber coloration (most balls were amber or blue). Along with the embossed pigeon, it also had the firm’s embossed name and address. Prior to being acquired by Frobouck, it was part of the Alex Kerr collection, which American Bottle Auctions also sold, in segments, from 2007-08.

In all, 31 target balls found new owners at the Peter Frobouck sale, which grossed approximately $70,000. Two balls failed to meet the seller’s reserve. Following are additional highlights from the auction. All prices quoted include a 12 percent buyer’s premium.

The second top lot of the sale also originated from the Alex Kerr Collection. It was a J.H. Johnston (also of Pittsburgh; there were five major manufacturers in Pittsburgh) target ball, in an extremely rare purple coloration. It soared to $14,560. The three-piece mold ball, in near-mint condition, featured a goodly amount of glass on the base and a staggering amount of embossing.

A three-piece mold, burst lip, 2.4-ounce target ball made by Jas. Brown & Son (also of Pittsburgh), graded 9.5 out of 10 for condition and boasting a light yellowish amber coloration, loads of embossing and great character, breezed to $10,080. Also, a near-mint E.E. Sage & Co. (Chicago) 2.1-ounce ball, light to medium amber, with large-letter embossing, brought $4,928.

A 2.6-ounce glass ball from Capt. A.H. Bogardus of Chicago (who had target balls made for him by several glasshouses), mint 9.8, medium to deep amber and with a rare embossed bottom, realized $4,704. Also, a target ball with stars (or crosses), 3-piece mold, 2.2 ounces, with a finely ground lip, razor-thin seams and a handsome warm amber coloration, garnered $2,464.

The top earner of the foreign-made balls was an E. Barton & Sons (U.K.) sand ball in varying shades of light blue, with baby mottled blue patches and green spots. Graded mint 9.8, the bottle had thousands of tiny bubbles throughout and went for $1,232. Another E. Barton & Sons ball, this one an elaborately designed brilliant blue orb graded a stout 9.9, rose to $952.

A German-made Sophienhutte In Ilmenau (Thur) amber colored target ball, 2.2 ounces, with an unusual lattice pattern and in 9.6 condition despite a dent in the bottom side, peaked at $896; while a rare Australian-made target ball with beautiful blue coloring and a two-piece design that turned from a square pattern to an odd geometric design on each side brought $896.

An amethyst Gablonz target ball (made in Germany and very rare and well made, despite being somewhat oddly shaped), 1.8 ounces and a little bit smaller than the standard 3-inch ball, pear-shaped and graded a solid 9.7, went for $896; and a Bogardus target ball made in 1877, with purple and clear coloring and some green near the top, graded 9.7, changed hands for $840.

There are no target ball auctions planned for anytime in the near future by American Bottle Auctions. “There just aren’t that many collections out there, so it’s anybody’s guess when we’ll have another one,” shrugged Wichmann. “My advice is just to watch eBay and keep an eye on our website. You just never know. One thing’s for sure, they’re gaining in popularity.”

American Bottle Auctions’ next big online bottle auction is tentatively scheduled for sometime in September, with a time and date to be determined (see www.AmericanBottle.com for info). The firm is always accepting quality consignments for future sales. To consign a single piece or an entire collection, you may call them at 1-800-806-7722, or e-mail them at info@americanbottle.com.

For more information about American Bottle Auctions and its calendar of upcoming events, visit www.AmericanBottle.com. For more information about target balls, visit the websites www.targetballs.com and www.glasstargetballs.com. Inquiries about target balls may be directed to Ralph Finch, an expert on the subject, at rfinch@twmi.rr.com.


MORE RESOURCES FOR ANTIQUE COLLECTORS and DEALERS

Great books, CDs, price guides & more

Warman’s Antiques & Collectibles 2011 Price Guide

Interact with other antique collectors in Antique Trader’s online forum

Get up-to-date pricing for tens of thousands of antiques & collectibles on Collect.com – FREE for 1 year – when you join the Collecting Insider Club!

Browse hundreds of FREE online classified ads

Sign up for your FREE AntiqueTrader.com email newsletter

For more columns and features for antique dealers, restorers and collectors, get your own subscription to Antique Trader magazine

More Images:

featuredImage
2.6-ounce target ball from Capt. A.H. Bogardus of Chicago, in mint 9.8 condition ($4,704).
featuredImage
Target ball with stars (or crosses), 3-piece mold, 2.2 ounces, warm amber coloration ($2,464).
featuredImage
The top earner of the foreign-made balls was this E. Barton & Sons (U.K.) sand ball ($1,232).
featuredImage
Near-mint E.E. Sage & Co. (Chicago) 2.1-ounce target ball, light to medium amber ($4,928).
featuredImage
J.H. Johnston (Pittsburgh) target ball, in an extremely rare purple coloration ($14,560).
featuredImage
Three-piece mold, 2.4-ounce target ball made by Jas. Brown & Son of Pittsburgh ($10,080).

Leave a Reply