Escaping the Ordinary: Houdini Memorabilia enchants Collectors

Houdini memorabilia stole the show at a recent sale by Potter & Potter Auctions. The most appealing lots were the ones that offered a peek behind the curtain.

Buried Alive! Cleveland: Otis Litho., ca. 1924. Eight-sheet color lithographed poster advertising a sensational stunt that Houdini would never perform – his escape from a coffin buried under mounds of heavy earth.
Image courtesy of Potter & Potter Auctions.

Stage magicians’ props and memorabilia continue to enchant collectors, and escape artist Harry Houdini remains one of the greatest names of all time. A recent sale of Houdiniana & Magic Memorabilia by Potter & Potter Auctions on April 26 kept the show going with rare items selling at high prices. The auction house’s selection of highlights, chosen before the sale, turned out to be predictions worthy of a psychic—except that the estimates often proved low.

Houdini Brothers and Family Photograph. Circa 1915. Image courtesy of Potter & Potter Auctions.

Collectors of Houdiniana find the magician himself, born Erik Weisz in 1874 (or, more accurately, Weisz Erik, to use the name order of his native Budapest), as interesting as any of his onstage feats. Auction highlights included photographs of Houdini with family members. Lot number 1, a candid photo of Houdini with his family, sold for $9,600, smashing its presale estimate of $3,000-6,000. The rare image, believed to be unpublished, is one of the few known pictures of Houdini with his mother, Cecelia Steiner Weiss. Also pictured are his wife, Beatrice, and his four brothers, Nat, Leo, Bill, and Theo, the last of whom was also a magician and performed as “Hardeen, brother of Houdini.”

Portrait of Beatrice and Harry Houdini. Chicago: Butler, 1920s. Image courtesy of Potter & Potter Auctions.

Another photo of Houdini, this one with his wife, sold for $6,000, an astounding five times its high estimate of $1,200. It is a staged portrait, with Beatrice’s arms around her husband’s shoulders, looking into the camera and smiling.

Gimbel Brothers Packing Case Challenge letter. Image courtesy of Potter & Potter Auctions.

This isn’t to say that items related to Houdini’s stage shows command less interest or lower prices. In 1925, the Gimbel Brothers firm issued a framed letterpress notice of a challenge to Houdini, offering to make a packing case “that you will be unable to escape therefrom.” This case sold for $9,600, over ten times its high estimate of $900.

La Glace Liquide magic mirror. Image courtesy of Potter & Potter Auctions.

While Houdini received top billing, he wasn’t the only magician whose memorabilia conjured up high prices. A trick mirror called “La Glace Liquide” from contemporary magic collector and prop maker Richard Gerlitz sold for $4,800, nearly doubling its high estimate of $2,500. It is used for a trick involving a silk handkerchief that appears to sink into the surface of the Art Nouveau-style mirror and vanish as if the glass were liquid.

Cleveland: The Otis Lithograph Co., [ca. 1929]. Bright color lithograph showing Thurston shooting a gun at a woman in a curtained cabinet above the stage. Image courtesy of Potter & Potter Auctions.

Plenty of colorful posters promoted magic acts in the early 20th century. Most of them carry an air of danger or mystique, with pictures of supernatural figures or death-defying stunts. An especially dramatic and uncommon poster promoting magician Howard Thurston, with a color lithograph showing him firing a gun at a figure in a cabinet suspended above the stage, doubled its presale estimate of $2,500 to sell for $5,040.

You may also like:

Elizabeth Heineman is a contributing editor for Kovels Antique Trader. She previously wrote and edited for Kovels, which may have been the best education she could have had in antiques. Her favorite thing about antiques and collectibles is the sheer variety of topics they cover.